Tax applied to redeemed points despite “no tax” setting, order total mismatches emails

← Back to Tickets
#B6J7Z8 Pending Public

Tax applied to redeemed points despite "no tax" setting, order total mismatches emails

wpclever.clarity251 clarity251 • WPC Smart Points & Rewards •
contact Staff
WPClever replied Nov 9, 2026 · 3:02 pm

Hi Clarity251,

Thank you for reporting this, and for the detailed description. We've identified the cause and fixed it.

What happened

Redeemed points are applied to the order as a negative fee. When "Redeem tax" is set to "No", the plugin correctly keeps that fee tax-free at checkout. That is why the order total and the emails were correct.

However, whenever WooCommerce later recalculates the order's taxes, it ignores the fee's tax-free setting for negative fees. This can happen when the order is recalculated by the checkout process, by the admin, or by another plugin or payment gateway. In that case WooCommerce spreads a tax reduction across the order, which deducted tax from the redeemed points on the order page. The emails had already been sent with the correct amounts, so the totals no longer matched. Removing that tax manually and updating the order, as you did, restored the correct total.

What we changed

  • The plugin now marks the redeemed-points line when the order is created.
  • Whenever WooCommerce recalculates the order's taxes, the plugin removes any tax from that line again if "Redeem tax" is set to "No".
  • Existing orders that were placed before this fix are also covered. The plugin recognizes their redeemed-points line and applies your current setting if they are recalculated.
  • If "Redeem tax" is set to "Yes", nothing changes.

Next steps

Please update to the new version 1.2.5 once it's released. After updating, you can test by placing an order with redeemed points and clicking "Recalculate" on the order page. The total should stay the same as in the emails.

clarity251
wpclever.clarity251
clarity251 replied Nov 5, 2026 · 9:59 pm

Just happened again. Customer redeemed points and taxes are deducted from the redeemed points despite the setting being turned off.

Screenshots attached.

WPClever
wpclever.clarity251
clarity251 started the conversation Oct 31, 2026 · 9:08 am

When the setting to not tax redeemed points is disabled in WPC Smart Points and Rewards, that setting is being ignored suddenly in an order today. Redeemed points still have tax applied on the order itself.

The emails sent to both the customer and the admin were correct. They did not deduct tax from the redeemed points, so the totals shown in those emails were accurate.

The problem is on the WooCommerce order page. When you open the order, tax was deducted from the redeemed points, and the order total there does not match what was in the emails.

To fix it, the order had to be opened manually, the tax on the redeemed points removed manually, and the order updated. Only then did the order total match the emails.

This looks like a bug in how the plugin calculates tax on the order record versus what it sends in the notification emails.